You are here:  Home  >  Livestock  >  Beef Cattle  >  Current Article

Will Cloned Cattle Give Us What We’re Looking For?

By   /  July 25, 2016  /  6 Comments

    Print       Email
If you followed the three part pictorial history of cattle size and type by Dr. Harlan Ritchie (see
    Print       Email

About the author

Publisher, Editor and Author

Kathy worked with the Bureau of Land Management for 12 years before founding Livestock for Landscapes in 2004. Her twelve years at the agency allowed her to pursue her goal of helping communities find ways to live profitably AND sustainably in their environment. She has been researching and working with livestock as a land management tool for over a decade. When she's not helping farmers, ranchers and land managers on-site, she writes articles, and books, and edits videos to help others turn their livestock into landscape managers.


  1. bill elkins says:

    Well it seems like there are cheaper ways to get calves on the ground, but even if increased value from sales covers that, other hurdles remain (as pointed out by Mr Hines). I would also question- how many descendants of these clones will breed true for their carcass traits for more than a few generations and/or in other environments, even if the breeding population is selected by ultrasound? Time will tell.
    Then too, although many chefs & consumers now prefer prime beef to leaner quality grades, how long will that fashion last, especially if prices rise? Tastes change (think popular music, hair styles), and there are other ways to finish cattle, as, I suspect, is well known to many who read On Pasture.

  2. Chip Hines says:

    Carcass value is only one part of profitability and many times is antagonistic to the cow calf rancher and his profits.

    I have been a vocal critic of cloning as the wrong cattle will be cloned!

    I know a professor at WTAMU, and although we have not discussed this particular proposition, I know what his answer will be. Very close to what I just posted.

    • Kathy Voth says:

      Tell us more, Chip, about how carcass value can be antagonistic to the cow calf rancher and his profits. I think folks would like to know. And if you could pick a cow and bull to clone to start a good breed, what would you choose? You always have good thoughts!

      • Chip Hines says:

        Thanks, Kathy. value to the Cow calf producer begins with the size and type cow to survive as much as possible with what the land produces. This cow must be easy fleshing. That means she easily puts on fat. This cow is more likely to breed early. Fat is an insulator. But, more important at is her winter supplement. A cow carrying fat will need less hay and less protein supplement as she is carrying It on her back.
        The perfect carcass animal being discussed carries very little fat to decrease trim. When cows got oversized during the period of 1970 too the last few years, they naturally became leaner. That caused more supplementation and hay feeding. Some for size, some for lack of fat for insulation and lack of energy from fat.

        Their total emphasis is on carcass. What about frame score and heifer weight? What size cow will they be when grown out? WTAMU is only thinking of their feedlot and packing industry.

        It is now being recognized that fat, animal fat, has less correlation to obesity as once claimed and that fat has a place in our diets.

        Which is most important? Cow efficiency or steer efficiency? This thought will evolve into another article I will submit to On Pasture to further explain the antagonisms. Thanks Kathy, for inviting me to explain my comment.

  3. Curt Gesch says:

    These calves were “naturally grazed” with their mothers on native grasses. Then confined in a feedlot for 185 days. One fourth of their lives (actually more than that) in a feedlot. “On pasture” must mean more than “preparation for confinement.” Cloned or not cloned, something seems wrong to me.

You might also like...

Flerds: Sheep and Cattle Grazing Together for Predator Protection and Pasture Management

Read More →
Translate »